Former X-Men ’97 Showrunner Criticizes What If…? Season 3 and Calls for Reinstatement

by Haley January 3, 2025

Former X-Men ’97 showrunner Beau DeMayo has publicly criticized Marvel’s What If…? season 3, comparing it to fanfiction and stating that he would rather watch water boil than finish the show. DeMayo’s comments have caused controversy, especially since Matthew Chauncey, the head writer for What If…? season 3, is set to take over X-Men ’97 in the upcoming season. DeMayo accuses Chauncey of lying about his knowledge of the rights surrounding the X-Men in the MCU. These developments, coupled with the lackluster reception of What If…? season 3, have led fans to call for DeMayo’s reinstatement as showrunner. However, his return seems unlikely as Marvel has not provided a clear reason for his firing.

Former X-Men ’97 Showrunner Criticizes What If…? Season 3 and Calls for Reinstatement

– Former X-Men ’97 showrunner Beau DeMayo criticizes season 3 of Marvel’s “What If…?” and compares it to fanfiction.
– DeMayo blames the lack of quality in What If…? on the new X-Men ’97 showrunner, Matthew Chauncey, and accuses him of lying about the X-Men rights in the MCU.
– Many fans are calling for DeMayo to be reinstated as showrunner for X-Men ’97, but it is unlikely to happen as the studio has not provided a clear reason for his firing.

Beau DeMayo, the former showrunner of X-Men ’97, has recently criticized Marvel’s animated series, What If…? season 3. Despite the lack of fanfare surrounding the finale of What If…?, DeMayo has taken to social media to share his negative thoughts on the show. He compared the dialogue to fanfiction and stated that he would rather watch water boil than finish the series.

DeMayo’s dissatisfaction with What If…? seems to stem from his own experience as a showrunner. Matthew Chauncey, the head writer for What If…? season 3, is set to take over X-Men ’97 in season 3, using DeMayo’s scripts from the previous season as a baseline. DeMayo lays the blame for the lack of quality in What If…? on Chauncey, accusing him of lying about his knowledge of the X-Men rights in the MCU.

DeMayo’s frustration extends to the studio as well. Despite the calls for DeMayo to be reinstated as showrunner for X-Men ’97, it is unlikely to happen as the studio has not released any clear statement about why he was fired. This suggests that there may be serious reasons for his dismissal that cannot be easily overlooked.

The reception to What If…? season 3 has been underwhelming, which only adds fuel to the fire of DeMayo’s criticism. Many fans and viewers are disappointed with the series, further supporting DeMayo’s claims about its lack of quality.

Although DeMayo’s criticisms have gained attention, it is unlikely that he will return to the MCU anytime soon. The studio’s silence on the reasons for his firing indicates that there may be unresolved issues that prevent his reentry into the Marvel universe.

In conclusion, Beau DeMayo, the former showrunner of X-Men ’97, has openly criticized Marvel’s animated series, What If…? season 3. His negative comments about the show’s dialogue and overall quality have sparked a discussion among fans and viewers. However, despite the calls for his reinstatement as showrunner, it is unlikely that DeMayo will return to the MCU given the studio’s failure to release any clear statement about the reasons for his firing. This suggests that there may be underlying issues that prevent his comeback. As the future of X-Men ’97 and the Marvel Cinematic Universe unfold, the reception and criticism of What If…? season 3 will continue to be a part of the conversation.