The Strangers: Chapter 1 Review – A Disappointment in Disguise

by Haley May 16, 2024

In a genre perpetually regurgitating the same tired tropes, “The Strangers: Chapter 1” has the audacity to position itself as a fresh entry in horror cinema. Directed by Renny Harlin, who seems to be reliving his “Die Hard 2” glory days, the film plods along the well-worn path of its predecessors, only to trip over its own clichés.

The Strangers: Chapter 1 Review – A Disappointment in Disguise

The premise is as uninspired as it gets: Maya (Madelaine Petsch) and Ryan (Froy Gutierrez), a pair of generic protagonists, break down in a dreary town named Venus, Oregon. They take refuge in a rental house that screams “bad decision,” and sure enough, they find themselves besieged by masked intruders. This setup, already stale from overuse, does little to distinguish itself, relying instead on the audience’s nostalgia for the original 2008 film, which, let’s be honest, wasn’t exactly a masterpiece either.

The film attempts to build tension with scenes that include unsettling encounters at a local diner and ominous glances from creepy townsfolk. Unfortunately, any semblance of suspense is swiftly obliterated once the home invasion begins. What follows is a tedious sequence of predictable scares and graphic violence that fails to deliver any real sense of dread. The script seems to believe that throwing more blood and guts at the screen will compensate for its lack of originality. Spoiler alert: it doesn’t.

Take, for instance, the much-touted scene where Maya puts her hand through a nail in the crawlspace. Her silent scream, while briefly effective, is emblematic of the film’s overall approach—shock value devoid of substance. Instead of exploring the psychological horror of their predicament, the film is content to wallow in gratuitous brutality. This emphasis on gore over genuine terror leaves the audience more desensitized than horrified, a fatal flaw for a movie that aspires to be a thriller.

The character development—or lack thereof—is another glaring issue. Petsch and Gutierrez do their best with the scraps they’re given, but their roles are so thinly written that it’s hard to muster any real concern for their fate. Maya and Ryan are less characters than they are placeholders, moving through the plot on autopilot. Meanwhile, the masked assailants are reduced to mere boogeymen, their lack of motive or backstory once a source of chilling ambiguity, now a lazy shortcut that underscores the script’s deficiencies.

Harlin’s direction offers occasional glimpses of his talent, particularly in the film’s action sequences. The practical effects are a welcome touch, grounding the horror in a tangible reality. Yet, these moments are few and far between, lost amidst the film’s relentless barrage of uninspired scares and plodding narrative. The pacing, particularly in the middle act, is sluggish, draining the film of any momentum and leaving viewers checking their watches more often than their pulses.

The climax teases future installments, a promise that falls flat given the underwhelming nature of this opening chapter. The idea of a trilogy might have seemed clever in the boardroom, but “The Strangers: Chapter 1” does little to justify such ambition. The supposed twists and connections to the original films feel more like afterthoughts, tacked on in a desperate bid to spark interest in sequels that, if this film is any indication, will be just as forgettable.

In the end, “The Strangers: Chapter 1” is a disappointing addition to a franchise that never quite lived up to its potential. The film’s reliance on tired tropes and uninspired scares renders it a forgettable experience, even for die-hard horror fans. Despite its atmospheric setting and a few standout moments, it fails to breathe new life into the series. For a film that promised to be a terrifying journey, it instead serves as a reminder of how stagnant the horror genre can be when it refuses to innovate.

RATING: 1.5 out of 5.0

The Strangers: Chapter 1 is in theaters on May 17th, 2024.