Totally Killer Review: A Failed Attempt at Genre-Blending
โTotally Killerโ attempts to carve out its own space by blending teen slasher and time-travel genre elements, but without either of the chops to pull it off. The film, directed by Nahnatchka Khan, stars Kiernan Shipka as Jamie, a modern-day teenager who finds herself transported back to the 1980s, where she must navigate a world of casual misogyny, big hair, and, most importantly, a killer on the loose.
The filmโs premise is undeniably intriguing, echoing classics like โBack to the Futureโ and โHappy Death Day.โ Itโs a Halloween offering that aims to be both a perky comedy and a suspenseful horror, but the execution leaves much to be desired. While the film does make some inspired choices, such as flashing back to the present day to keep the audience engaged, it often falls into the trap of being overly familiar. The filmโs attempts at self-aware humor, name-checking other movies, and relying on genre tropes, come off as more smug than clever.


One of the filmโs strengths lies in its exploration of the culture clash between the โ80s and the present day. Shipkaโs character, Jamie, serves as the audienceโs surrogate, her progressive Gen Z sensibilities often at odds with the retrograde politics of the time, but itโs not enough to elevate โTotally Killerโ above its derivative nature.
Where the film truly falters is in its lack of atmospheric direction and its failure to effectively stage its slasher scenes. The kills lack suspense or menace, and the visual style is as bland as a daytime soap. This is particularly disappointing given the film aims to be a horror-comedy, a notoriously difficult combination of genres to nail.
Sadly, โTotally Killerโ is a film that promises much but delivers little. Its attempts to blend comedy, horror, and time-travel tropes result in a mash-up that lacks the charisma to make its concept sing. While it does offer moments of cultural insight and features a mostly engaging performance from Shipka, these are not enough to save it from its shortcomings.
RATING: 2.0 out of 5
Totally Killer is now streaming on Amazon Prime Video.
Bernat Baby Blanket Terracotta Yarn - 1 Pack of 300g/10.5 oz - 100% Polyester - #6 Super Bulky - 220 Yards - Knitting/Crochet
$11.99 (as of April 4, 2025 09:38 GMT -07:00 - More info)Whereโs your crazy Naughty Baby Simulator Daddy Prank
$11.99 (as of April 4, 2025 09:38 GMT -07:00 - More info)Waterproof Desk matโExcel Cheat Sheet Desk padโContains 12 Types of Common Skills in Excel and WordโLarge XL Gaming Mouse pad|Office Keyboard pad|Computer mat with excel Shortcuts
$16.99 (as of April 4, 2025 09:38 GMT -07:00 - More info)Amazon Basics 48-Pack AA Alkaline High-Performance Batteries, 1.5 Volt, 10-Year Shelf Life
$14.27 (as of April 4, 2025 09:38 GMT -07:00 - More info)Auto Amazon Links: No products found. (68 items filtered out)
Interesting concept but it didnโt quite hit the mark for me. The blend just felt a bit off. Keep trying though!
I was really hoping for more with โTotally Killer.โ The mix of horror and comedy just didnโt land for me. It had some fun moments, but overall, it felt like it couldnโt quite decide what it wanted to be.