Indiana Jones and the City of the Gods

Share

image

Who would have thought Iโ€™d be READING Indy IV? Since I erased Crystal Skull from my mind, this seems to be my sole Indy IV experience. Iโ€™m on page 85 and so far there are staggering differences. Who has read it? What do you think? Letโ€™s get the boulder rolling.

Author

You may also like...

No Responses

  1. mdhuff says:

    Iโ€™ve not read it yet.  But I will.  Comments to come.

  2. Fats says:

    I loved City of the Gods. I liked the movie just fine, but I think this is a far greater level of craftsmanship in the writing. It seems like a lot of these action sequences were funnier and more creative, and the Marion / Indy dynamic was far, far more true Raiders.

    Reading this made some of the hackneyed transitions in Crystal Skull make more sense to me, because I could see where David Koepp was forced to do awkward surgery.

    I donโ€™t know what they didnโ€™t like about this draftโ€“ and this draft certainly isnโ€™t perfectโ€“ but Iโ€™m a little stunned that they didnโ€™t keep more of it. Indy getting drunk in the museum was particularly inspired, as was the final resolution of his relationship with Marion.

    :shrug:

    Iโ€™d give the movie a B-, and give this script an A-.

  3. junky says:

    From Jason Bylan:

    I actually started reading it a few days ago. All I needed to see was the first line to know it was graphic matching into anything other than a mole hill.

    Iโ€™m about 1/3rd way (heโ€™s going to South America) and thusforth has no mention of a Shia LeBouef character or Marion. Itโ€™s interesting in that it indeed is following the key story (presumably laid out by Lucasโ€“ Russians in a warehouse, Nuclear bomb scene, hyptotising Skull, a scene involving the statue of a dead Marcus Brody) but doing them as a totally, or near-totally, different movie.  I did love the clock scene (oddly, almost a year ago at Central Park I stood by the Childrenโ€™s Zoo clock and thought that areaโ€“ not necessarily the clock itselfโ€“ but that Natural History area would be a great location for the college Indy teaches at) and the engine thing was cool.  So yeah, so far it is better but then again there are things I liked in the real one that are missing (the gunpowder showing the way in the warehouse, the motorcycle chase skidding under the tables in the college).  Iโ€™ll definitely finish it soon.

    I will say though on record Darapont ripped off my idea of having a scene in a museum!!!!

    Jason

  4. junky says:

    Indy gettting drunk in the museum and stealing the fertility idol was the scene that made me think of a young Hugh Sterbakov waking up in a sweat of sudden inspiration and then giggling as he typed the scene in the middle of the night.

  5. DougGold says:

    What I preferred about this script is that it was far less cartoony than the filmed script.  Even though Indy survives the atomic blast in a fridge, we donโ€™t see it tumble over and over in a way that would clearly have killed him.  We get to respect a statue of Marcus instead of having the statueโ€™s head fall on the Russianโ€™s car.  Marion is a real character.  We donโ€™t see the Ark. Yuri was more believable than Cate Blanchettโ€™s character.  Far less corny dialogue (though I canโ€™t believe they had Yuri say โ€˜Adventure has a nameโ€™ twice, much less once.) Why did Lucas cram the filmed version full of โ€˜50s speech (โ€œI like Ike!โ€) and unbelievable moments.  In this script, the russians SNEAK into the army base undetected.  Far more believable than the filmed scene where a dozen russians take over the whole base.  Itโ€™s clear that in the early โ€˜80s Lucas stopped thinking like a film student and started thinking like a producer of blockbusters.  I miss the old George.